Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Pandora Case


Problem/Issue Statement

The current problem that Pandora faces is the issue of balancing interests of its capital investors while maintaining Pandora’s core values. Another key problem is the threat of licensing costs which investors stated many different opinions about these costs. Pandora needs to find a way to turn their revenue into profits.

Pandora’s operating model currently does not have the right people for the correct tasks. The person that realized the main problem was Tim Westergren. Due to the fact that Pandora is not producing enough revenue to maintain an efficient operation process, Pandora cannot invest in advertising to try and engage in new customers.

The scope of the problem was somewhat linked to the lack of leadership. Pandora’s strategy lacked the strength to find new customers. Pandora lacked the ability to find out what consumers wanted. Therefore Pandora made a strategic change to a direct-to-consumer Internet radio system which was their online website.


Situation Assessment

The context of the problem was Pandora’s lack of ability to advertise to new customers in which they could expand their market share. This could create the ability to gain a larger profit even before their creation of their Internet service. The gross margin from revenue to costs was about $ 0.69 per hour in 2007. The problem occurred when Pandora realized that they weren’t spending a dollar on marketing, which was detrimental to their customer base.

The decision criteria for Pandora exemplified the small amount of business-oriented requirements in which they remained different by having a free service. Therefore Pandora needs to focus on their ability to reach out to new customers via phone and other services along with different types of memberships.


List/Evaluation of Plausible Alternatives Courses of Action



Pandora can continue to do exactly what they have been doing. This would cause no costs to make changes and no time spent to change the process such as updating the systems. The problem with keeping this process is that it would not maximize revenues per customer. Their would be no operating capital to enhance the business and Pandora would not increase their customer base because of the lack of advertising.

The first alternative for Pandora is to change to a Premium Subscription Model. This model would offer a premium membership with key values added such as certain song selection, AdFree, and many more. The Premium model would also create a limited number of free usages to all users, which would be set as a maximum on a monthly basis. The only problem with this alternative is that Pandora would be limited on a monthly basis for the usage of new users in which this would force users to subscribe if they want to abolish ads.

The second alternative for Pandora would be to change to an Ad-Based Model, which would include subscription incentives. This system would increase revenue because of partnerships with other companies who would be wiling to advertise. Subscribers would have the option to reduce the amount of ads by answering specific questions about their music preferences, which will help expand their library of songs. This system would help target advertising for referrals, which could lead to certain fees if users purchase. The negatives that come along with adopting the Ad-Based Model is that the extra advertising simply will not encourage new users to fully adopt the new service and will force users to subscribe if they want to decrease the amount of ads.


Recommendation

A quality recommendation for Pandora would be to maintain the free service that is currently provided to customers. Pandora should offer the Premium Priced Ad-Free Internet radio service while focusing on their ability to find new customers. They must find a way to gain profit returns to investors through economies of scale which would include bringing in new free customers to address Pandora’s inability to maximize their returns to their customers. The best recommendation for Pandora overall would to heavily consider changing their system to the Ad-Based model which would provide subscription options. This model would allow customers to become free users by listening to the ads. The other incentive for customers would allow the customer to choose the model that decreases the amount of ads in which they could use subscriber input for targeted ads.


Presentation

A quality presentation would sum up the Pandora case by explaining how the changes would affect the company strategy. The presentation would focus on the alternatives along with the option for Pandora to keep doing what they have been doing. An important fact to mention would be that technology is improving at a fast rate in which Pandora would have to keep up. Therefore I would mention how Pandora can continue to deliver a great product to their customers. 


Reflection

After analyzing the consultant’s presentation, a decision was made that their presentation was very professional and efficient. They showed that they fully understood the challenges that Pandora is facing. Since 2008, we have not generated profits to date in which we need to find a way to increase revenues and decrease costs in the near future. We still need to bring in potential investors to assure them that our plans for the future are evident.

The consultants clearly discussed the five courses of action and then evaluated each individual action. Their first alternative was to mass market their product into social media such as Facebook. This could increase subscription and advertising revenues, which the consultants mentioned would conclude in over $2 million over the next two years. Their second alternative was to have applications for mobile devices, which would generate revenues of $0.99 per download. This would be effective immediately and was a well thought out alternative. The third alternative was to implement a tiered cost structure for subscribers and the fourth was to insert 15-second audio ads. The last alternative involved selling the company for about $35.1 million. These consultants presented these alternatives in an effective and realistic manor.

The consultants were very passionate in their decision to recommend the second, third, and fourth alternative along with the recommendation to not pursue the social media marketing or selling off the company. Overall I agree with the consultants that these alternatives would be most effective as of course I previously mentioned in my preparation. The one disagreement that I have with the consultants is to shy away from using social media. This is an easy way to advertise your product and would be easy to align our business strategy with social media.

Overall the future looks bright with our plan to examine these alternatives. My thoughts are to implement any of the four alternatives that were mentioned. The execution of implementing these alternatives are crucial as we have to always keep in mind that the most important thing is our customers. The future looks great if we can execute these alternatives. With our strategy, we should feel very confident with our future plans.