Monday, March 25, 2013

Bombardier Case


Problem/Issue Statement

The current problem for Bombardier is the two ERP inefficiencies with the Mirabel plant and the Saint-Laurent location. While these locations were increasing with success, there were still certain flaws that need to be fixed. Looking forward to the third ERP installation the company simply needs to fix these flaws between its implementation and the best practices regarding the consultants, press, and companies.

The main problem is the current disagreement between the project team and the company employees regarding the validity of processes and the methodologies. When looking at the symptoms we can see that there is an inefficient concentration of knowledge with the users, project structure, and employees.

The current scope of the problem is the ERP systems at Mirabel and Saint-Laurent along with the locations where the ERP system will be implemented in the near future for Bombardier. Bombardier is planning to switch from their current legacy system to the ERP system, which will be an essential change to the company.

Situation Assessment

The context of the problem is that Bombardier is one of the leading manufacturers for aerospace and transportation, which they have reported over $8 billion in 2007. Bombardier has realized that they have to change their legacy system to an ERP system. The first test for the ERP system at the Mirabel plant did not go so well because the users were frustrated due to a lack of communication between the project team and the employees. However, the second test went a lot more efficient as the trained employees were prepared and the message was delivered from management to the employees in a more understanding manor.

The decision criteria will and should determine a solution for the ERP practices to be established. An efficient ERP implementation of the 12 Best Practices should present as follows:

1. Executive management should endorse the ERP project. Implementation by VPs sponsorship.
2. Executive management should remain actively involved throughout the implementation. Implementation by executive policy committees to ensure
project governance.
3. ERP software implementation responsibilities should be shared between the IT department and functional areas where the software is being
implemented. Implemented by policy committees involving senior management and the implementation team consisting of IT personnel.
4. Executive management should be cognizant about the institution’s ability to adapt to the organizational changes that occur when ERP software is
implemented. Implemented by being aware of Shock and Shock Relief.
5. A project manager should be assigned the full-time to the implementation.
6. The project team composition should represent all functional areas where the software will be implemented. Implementation through all systems.
7. Project team members’ normal job responsibilities should be reassigned to other employees for the project duration.
8. Employees should receive training on how to work as a team on a project before implementation begins.
9. The institution should retain ownership of the implementation process. “Skills transfer” from consultant to company.
10. All employees who will use the software should receive thorough training.
11. The institution should change its administrative processes to fit the software. (Must be accepted to end users)
12. Implementation information should be continuously communicated to the business community.

List/Evaluation of Plausible Alternatives Courses of Action

The possible course of action would be to change the implementation process to the ERP best practice approach. Bombardier could make multiple changes in the company’s approach or simply copy the approach that was taken in the Saint-Laurent location without any major changes.

The first alternative that could be made is to improve Best Practice 3 & 6. The current issue with these practices is the lack of cohesion between Project Team and End Users along with a lack of accuracy in progress reporting. The recommended action would be to include function specialists in design and implementation activities, set in place formal process for accurate & real time scorecard progress, and diversify Support Team to include Super Users & function specialists along with IT. The immediate impact that this would cause is an increased cohesion between business and IT implementation, ensures deadlines are met and that there are smoother transitions to the new system, decreased vision, and reduction in costs.

The second alternative that could be made is to improve Best Practice 9. The current issue with this practice is that currently Bombardier is employing SAP developers who lack the Subject Matter Expertise to provide internal support, which would require SAP support. Therefore the recommended action would be to hire IT specialists on a full time basis who could phase out the reliance on the consultants (SAP developers) who don’t specialize in this specific function. The impact that this would have is reduction in costs because the onboard employees would cost less than the consultants. The second impact is that the usual problems that occur on a daily basis would be immediately resolved because of the IT specialists.

The third alternative that could be made is to improve Best Practice 11. The current issue with this practice is the current disconnect between the contact management process and SAP system cost. The recommended course of action is to establish a standardized contract process and expand the SAP features to accommodate the improved process. This would eliminate inefficiencies regarding costs while retaining partial low cost contract savings, which simply would utilize the system more efficiently.

Recommendation

My recommendation before preparing for the consultants’ presentation is to adopt the changes of the four practices based upon their net impact. For Best Practice 3 & 6 Bombardier should include departmental specialists in design and implementation activities, diversify Support Team of Super Users and Departmental specialists along with IT, and set in place formal process for accurate & real time scorecard progress. For Best Practice 9 Bombardier should simply hire IT specialist’s experts on a full time basis and phase out reliance on consultants (Certified SAP developers). Regarding Best Practice 11, Bombardier should establish a broad but standardized contract process and expand the SAP features to accommodate the improved processes.

Presentation

The consultants’ presentation should be very specific for which activities in the company’s implementations should be changed to better fit the practices. It should also include a large amount of information on each best practice that they have chosen for their standards. The consulting team should explain all of the adjustments to the current policies and state the costs of each one. They should also discuss the impact that this would have along with the efficiency of each change. The consultants should offer a fair view that states the improvements that could be made regarding the Mirabel location. Overall the consultants should give a solid overview on all of the practices along with which ones should be rectified.

Reflection


After looking over last night’s presentation I still believe that Bombardier can take several steps to enhance the implementation procedure. This is imminent after Bombardier stated the first and second test of the ERP system a success. I am in agreement with the consultant’s suggestion that the existing inefficiencies in the implementation process should follow the best practices between the IT department and functional areas pertaining to the software implementation, internal process, and company ownership.

One of the most interesting parts of the consultant’s presentation was the suggestion to hire IT specialist and eliminate reliance on Bombardier’s consultants in order to increase the consultant’s knowledge of the internal SAP’s. I can see how this is a possible solution but I still believe that cycling the business employees occasionally to the support team would be a more effective solution. The main inefficiency with the consultant’s proposal is that I personally cannot comprehend how 3 SME’s will effectively replace 400 SAP developers simply because of the workload.

Another key point that I found intriguing was the consultant’s illustration of the problems regarding the contract management processes. I agree that rewarding contract agents for negotiating cheaper contracts is inefficient due to lengthier contract negotiations. I believe adopting a hybrid approach that would standardize the process and expand SAP features would be effective although I believe input from the contract agents would be ideal in order to receive their thoughts on if this suggestion would resolve their complaints about the new contract management procedures.

The final point that I found intriguing is the consultant’s suggestions to include specialists regarding the project management team in order enhance interactions between the project team and the ends users pertaining to the implementation process. I agree with this suggestion as it indicates that more internal employees would join the project team to gain more knowledge of the situation so that it is not so heavily focused on just a few individuals. Although I agree with this suggestion, I do, however believe that the core costs of $560,000 indicated by the consultants could be more than the actual result. Conversely, I believe this cost is worth the two-month absence of the most efficient talent. Furthermore, the additional costs of $11,000 indicated by the consultants is also a bit understated but these specialists are extremely smart and valuable in which therefore Bombardier would have to hire these specialists in order to operate efficiently.

In conclusion, I agree with most of the suggestions that were made by the consulting team. However, I would suggest that functional specialists are included in the project management team in which they would be trained before their movement. We should examine in more detail whether or not hiring SME’s to replace the SAP’s would be the right decision as of course this is a major factor and decision. Lastly, Bombardier should rectify the contract management system by creating standardized processes and by expanding the SAP structure after they consult with the contract agents. All of these factors would conclude in a more efficient ERP implementation with the foundation of the best practices, which will result in an overall satisfaction from Bombardier.

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Accenture Case


Problem/Issue Statement

The Accenture IT is considering adopting COBIT 5, which could indicate that there is a potential for a hardware upgrade along with training to bring the organization up to date on the new solution. Accenture has accomplished a large amount of efficiency with its IT and with the adoption of COBIT 5 Accenture could receive more sufficient information related to business decisions, better projects and IT systems, and decrease the amount of risk. The main scope of the issue is Accenture’s operations. They operate in tons of locations across the globe which are supported by Accenture’s IT systems in which they are all affected by an minor or major changes that is made by the operations associated through COBIT 5.

Situation Assessment

Accenture’s IT system has improved throughout the years after they made many changes which was essential for today’s decision to adopt COBIT 5. Accenture used many important tools when this change occurred. They used a single vendor to meet the application needs. The second tool was the new IT system, which included efficient management along with IT staff using a Return on Investment strategy along with some corporate strategies. The third tool was running a business through their IT system opposed to a cost center. The final tool was when they reduced costs by using a SAP system.

COBIT 5 will cause Accenture to ensure the solutions in regards to risk IT, valuation IT, IT assurance framework, and business models related to information security. The decision is whether or not Accenture can adopt COBIT 5 without changing their management framework. COBIT 5 will improve Accenture’s IT structure and could cause operations to be updated. This could later result in an improved use of their resources without making significant changes to their business.

List/Evaluation of Plausible Alternatives Courses of Action

The first alternative is to implement a COBIT 5 framework. This would alter IT enterprise, project division, existing controls, general IT processes, and applications. The objectives of COBIT 5 would be a single integrated framework, which could be very effective. However the IT system would demand a change to adapt to the separation between management and compliance. COBIT 5 is free but the training is essential for use of COBIT, which costs around $175, which includes enabling processes, implementation, assessment, principles, information security, and information security. Determining an exact cost would be extremely difficult because we can’t predict how many employees would need the training. Regardless there is a important cost of time. Employees would have to use a large amount of time to learn the system, which could be a detrimental cost.

The second alternative for Accenture is to use the current IT Management Framework. Accenture would have to find a way to improve their current framework by continuing to reduce the amount of spending and it’s IT expenses. Accenture has proven to do this in the past along with improve employee satisfaction with more efficient IT services. Accenture must enhance its IT structure and management to keep its expectations for their technology to increase revenue and reduce costs for IT. Without these expectations, Accenture would not be able to go forward with their existing system.

Recommendation

The correct recommendation for this case would to not adopt the COBIT 5 system. Adopting the COBIT 5 system would decrease revenue and decrease the efficiency of operations. Accenture’s only use for COBIT is to used some of its ideas to improve their current IT structure. Accenture could change its IT system to relate them towards COBIT’s principles to help improve their current IT Framework. Accenture has currently made many improvements to their developmental procedures and could continue to do so in the near future.

Presentation

The presentation should include a sufficient overview on Accenture’s IT Framework to give the audience a complete understanding of the current Framework. The main part of the presentation should be about COBIT 5 and what it has to offer such as the costs, figures, and of course benefits. The possibility of obtaining those benefits should be discussed as well to present a realistic approach. The process of implementation would be a key part of the presentation to show whether or not the implementation and training would be easy or difficult. The consultants should end with the current improvement of Accenture’s IT Framework and briefly explain how they are on the path for an essential improvement in the future.



Reflection

After taking insightful time reviewing yesterday’s evaluation of COBIT 5 I am confident enough to reject the implementation of COBIT 5. The model that Accenture created is extremely valuable because is has been successful in the past regarding the framework, processes, and external set of controls; the consultants confirmed this with yesterday’s discussion. The consultants also discussed key factors for Accenture’s success with their current system. Those key factors explained how Accenture was ranked the highest regarding there the IT system, IT expense per employee, and IT expense for the percentage of net revenue.

A very intriguing fact is that the revenue and employee increase was all created through a simplistic governance and management system, which was successful through single vendor’s who created efficient applications and servers. As the consultants mentioned, adopting COBIT 5 would create complexity which most of the time is frowned upon. I agree with the consultants that Accenture has created a set of processes that are personalized to the company which provide more value to the staff and clients opposed to what COBIT 5 offers. Adopting COBIT 5 would demand a change in our IT governance, which could be detrimental to the marginal benefit for Accenture.

Overall the current IT system has been supported throughout the company’s growth and should continue to do so without constraints from COBIT 5. The consultants mentioned a few flaws with the current infrastructure such as the IT staff’s requirements, which were increased to be more important than a support staff along with a managerial component. Although these flaws were mentioned, COBIT 5 remains to be the wrong answer. My recommendation is for our IT management to create a review of current operations by assigning certain responsibilities to certain staff and urge these requirements for an audit of all the past projects. The final decision should be concluded by the internal management, which they will decide what option is most efficient for the company. As of right now, our company should maintain the existing IT infrastructure that has been servicing our company for years.