Monday, February 18, 2013

Junk Van Case


Problem/Issue Statement

The important problem that has taken place with Junk Van is that the IT system is flawed because Junk Van is having problems with handling errors and have proven to be non cost-effective. This is causing problems with data reports and scheduling for jobs.

The problem is that the IT system is inefficient which caused customers to be frustrated and has also produced many errors. Symptoms include mistakes regarding customer information, incorrect database entries; lengthy task time, poor data entry from drivers, incorrect scheduling, and billing errors.

The scope of the problem is the Junk Van organizational structure. The IT system has not been efficient enough because of the poor business model and lack of employee performance.

Situation Assessment

The context of the problem is that Junk Van’s business model demanded only electronic communications and did not require employees to report to physical locations. This caused the IT system to have scheduling errors along with incorrect data entry, which directly cause a loss of business.

The decision criteria is as follows:

- Flexibility to change the business model and industry
- Vendor support
- Cost effectiveness
- Ease of Implementation
- Ease of Use (Bad IT Skills)

List/Evaluation of Plausible Alternative Courses of Action

1) Microsoft Access Database: The company could upgrade to MS-Access, which cost $180 per computer. Junk Van should be able to afford this cost; the product could be installed on a shared server so that employees could have remote access. Junk Van could decide to install MS-Access themselves if they can figure out how to do that. This database would create a more united database in which would allow for employees to share tasks a lot easier. Drivers could us templates to send information in a more efficient manor. This decision would be very cost effective and would not be difficult to install.

2) Google Documents: The company could direct their company to google docs, which would take a minimal amount of time. Google docs would allow for users to edit the same sheet, which would be viewable to all users at the same time. Although this would be free, the key problem is that since google docs is fairly new which means their wouldn’t be an effective support team. Overall, this would allow the company to start this problem quickly for free.

3) Custom Application: Junk Van can pay an organization to build a custom application that would cost about $60 per hour for maintenance with absolutely no knowledge of how much maintenance would be demanded. Upfront costs could cost around $2000 in which Junk Van would not be able to review the system’s final product until the application was completed. This customized application would solve almost all IT problems that include a centralized database that can be accessed remotely and automated emails.

4) Platform as a Service: The company could choose to implement a platform as a service system, which would allow users to use popular applications along with build their own applications. This service could cost anywhere from $300 to $600 a month along with a fee of $180 per hour for customization. This system could scale down or up for the future and allows for users to be more flexible. This system might be the best choice as it could complete all IT needs. The only problem is that Junk Van might not be able to maintain this system on it’s own without a support team.

5) Enterprise Resource Planning System: This system would be installed around a centralized database that can be remotely accessed. A staggering cost of $2,500 per user for each year for each license could be a tough stat to get over. This cost does not include the start up fees, which could be just as expensive if not more than the license. This system has modules that include manufacturing and finance that could be easily implemented into Junk Van’s business demands. This option could fix the IT problems but the large costs could be the deciding factor in whether or not to change to this type of system.

Recommendation

The right recommendation for Junk Van is to upgrade from MS-Works to a Platform as a Service. This would simply solve the IT problems and would allow the company to improve the automated emailing and have a remotely accessible central database. This decision can only be made of course if Junk Van believes that they can implement this system themselves. Although this system is costly, it would be beneficial in the long-term because of how customizable it is which will allow Junk Van to update the system whenever it is needed. This system will decrease time delays, minimize errors, and will allow the company to demand whatever they desire.

Presentation

The most effective presentation should present all available alternatives, which each alternative is given the same amount of time that is presented. After that step is completed the decision should be clearly stated for which alternative is the correct one. The key reasons should be clear for why a specific alternative was chosen such as cost, product flexibility, implementation ease, and vendor support. I would be sure to present a weight benefits chart so that an interesting visual is involved. This would provide an atmosphere that shows an open-minded approach while at the same time provides a strong convincing atmosphere that the Platform as a Service system would be most effective for the future.


Reflection

I considered in detail whether or not I agreed or disagreed with the consultants. I came to the conclusion that I did agree with the consultants to upgrade to the Platform as a Service system. This system would solve the IT problems and would provide a more efficient system that wouldn’t cost a boatload. This decision would allow customization, flexibility, and support from the sellers.

After the group suggested the Platform as a Service system, I realized that what they were recommending was also similar to a SaaS system. They explained how important it is to maintain quality clients, which would keep the cost structure low. Using this system would abolish the emailing system, which was clearly outdated. This system would allow the company to expand into unique markets through franchising which would allow for company growth. Overall I thought they did a good job presenting all other alternatives and finally concluding which a powerful suggestion for what they would do.




No comments:

Post a Comment