Monday, February 11, 2013

P&G: Case Prep & Reflection




Problem/Issue Statement

Proctor and Gamble is facing an essential problem that needs to be rectified as soon as possible. This problem is that their pharmaceutical drugs are taking too long to hit the market due to the long process of clinical trials. Proctor and Gamble needs to figure out a way to reduce the time of this process while creating a more effective way to speed up the launch of their drugs to the market.

The difference between the problem and the symptoms is that the problem is simply the delay in the completion of the clinical trials opposed to the symptoms, which are the actual problems or inefficiencies for which are causing the clinical trials to take so long. 

The scope of the problem is that the clinical trials are not being managed correctly, which is an indicator that the entire data collection process demands rectification.

Situation Assessment

This issue could have very well dated back to the year of 2001 because the technology associated within the economy in the year of 2013 demands for a faster and more efficient product. The web based approach is approaching a time where Internet and technology is at a high but has not yet been perfected. Therefore P&G needs to adopt this approach and find a way to make it more efficient.

P&G has to focus on a cost-benefit analysis in order to decrease costs, which can be done by decreasing the amount of time it would take on collecting data. P&G needs to simply select the process that will take the least amount of time while also considering the position they project themselves to be in after selecting a specific option.

List of Plausible Alternative Courses of Action

1) The first alternative is to use a digital imaging system.
2) The second alternative is to majorly improve the paper based system.
3) The third alternative would be to switch to a web-enabled electronic document capture (EDC) system.

These three alternatives all address the key problem, which is decreasing the amount of time it takes to complete the clinical trials. The Digital Imaging system would decrease the process time because it would abolish paper deliveries because of the faxing option. If P&G improves the current paper based system, this could allow for a reduced amount of time needed to complete the process. This could be done by possibly hiring more employees so that the data could be processed faster. The web-enabled EDC system would be the most intriguing method because it would save an enormous amount of time because the data collection would be available immediately for the P&G databases.

Evaluation of Alternatives

The selection of what process to choose should be based on how the process would affect P&G in the long term while also considering which process would simply be more efficient. The process that takes the shortest amount of time while being the most efficient or effective should be the process that is chosen for P&G. This evaluation of course has to be based on how much each process would cost. This decision cannot be based off of what the employees feel would be more effective but simply on which process would cost the least. The decision needs to be realistic opposed to imaginative because the decision needs to be based off of what will happen opposed to what one thinks might happen.

Recommendation

A quality recommendation is one that considers all factors that will solve the problem by being realistic over long-term decisions. The factors that need to be considered are the health care division, site coordinators, and the competitors that are involved in the industry. The logical recommendation would be to choose the web-enabled EDC system because it would decrease the time for clinical trials while eliminating costs.

Presentation

The most effective presentation would sum up the case by acknowledging that the case indicates that the current system being used is not the future and that it hints that the web-based EDC system is the future. An effective presentation would provide a flowchart to show how the P&G system works. This would present an organized outline of the existing data management system. The reasons why the EDC system would be effective would be a demand in the presentation to show why this decision would be the correct choice. This would indicate how much time would be saved, decrease in costs, and the long-term benefits of implementing an EDC system. Although the EDC system is the correct decision, each process should be given a fair opportunity to be presented. This would provide an atmosphere that shows an open-minded approach while at the same time provides a strong convincing atmosphere that the web-based EDC system would be most effective for the future.


Reflection 

I was very pleased with the atmosphere of the presentation. I found the process a bit shocking because of how serious and realistic it was. After the presentation concluded I was happy that the group of consultants recommended that exact same argument that I recommended for P&G, which was the web-based- data entry system. The group made some key points that favored the EDC system that I found effective in which they were very confident that the paper based system should be removed. One of the things that I believe the group should have done was mention the other alternatives and show that they at least considered other alternatives. They completely ignored all other alternatives because they did not mention any other alternatives that were relevant. I believe that they were trying to sell their employees on the EDC opposed to simply stating the positives of each alternative and then suggest which they feel would be more beneficial for the company.

Due to the fact that this group had only a week to prepare, I believe they did a great job. They all presented for about the same amount of time and proved their points fairly well. The back and forth insight from the consultants and c-level executives were very entertaining and as I mentioned early it created a realistic approach. The c-level executives ask very intelligent questions which also helped the presentation as whole. I look forward to this upcoming weeks presentation and will look to be engaged as much as possible.

No comments:

Post a Comment